1950-1951

Thomas J. Hunt, Jr. President

Hasty Heart - Flora S. Curtis & Hope V. Carey*
The Glass Menagerie
Goodbye, My Fancy - Thomas J. Hunt Jr.

1951-1952

Ruth M. Johnston, President

Minnie Field; The Silver Whistle - Hope V. Carey
Double Door - Ruth Johnston
Light Up The Sky

1952-1953

Hope V. Carey, President

Gramercy Ghost
The Shop At Sly Corner
Father Of The Bride - Ruth Johnston

1953-1954

Richard W. Havens, President

Mr. Barry's Etchings - Walter J. Shunney
The Two Mrs. Carrolls - Hope V. Carey
Harvey - Lenny Gamache
(also played in Deertree, Maine)

1954-1955

A. Thomas Cooksey, President

Night of January 16th - Ruth J. Mulvaney 
(also played in Boothbay Harbor, Maine)
My Three Angels - Ralph Briggs
Sabrina Fair - Walter J. Shunney

1955-1956

A. Thomas Cooksey, President

Affairs of State - Ruth Johnston & Carol W. Henshaw
Dream Girl - Leonard F. Gamache (Asst: Ruth Gamache)
Tender Trap - Dr. Farrell
Gently Does It - Ruth Johnston

1956-1957

Frederick Lawton, President

Anniversary Waltz - Walter Shunney
Happy Birthday - Ralph Briggs
Late Love
Janus - Lenny Gamache

1957-1958

Lenny Gamache, President

Solid Gold Cadillac - Ralph Briggs
Dial "M" For Murder - Ronn Marshall
Broken Circle (performed for Family Service)
For Love Or Money - Ruth Johnston

1958-1959

Ruth Johnston - President

Call Me Madam - Lenny Gamache (Our First Musical)
Visit To A Small Planet - Ralph Briggs
The Mouse Trap - Ronn Marshall
Caine Mutiny Court Martial - Ruth Johnston

1959-1960 

Ruth Moody Donnelly, President

The Pajama Game - Lenny Gamache
The Seventh Veil - Ronn Marshall
Time Limit - Bill McMahon
Kind Sir

* Director listed where known